 |
Judges¡G
¡EMain judge: Patrick Su, Assistant Professor, Department of
Hotel Management, National Kaohsiung Hospitality College
¡EOther judges: Instructors from F&B departments in various
schools
Scoring Criteria
First Round and Finals¡G
|
Category |
% of Total |
Explanation |
| Dress & Carriage
|
10 |
1. Contestants awarded points based on overall style
¡ETeam members in Professional Division should wear the
same company uniform or basic restaurant service uniform,
plus a serviette draped over arm.
¡ETeam members in Student Division should wear same the
school uniform or basic restaurant service uniform, plus
a serviette draped over arm.
2. Stately carriage |
|
Tray-Carrying Posture
& Steadiness |
40 |
1. Tray-carrying posture, carriage
& pick-up posture.
2. steadiness
3. Whether or not anything was dropped on the ground. |
Safety & Hygiene |
10 |
Cleanliness/tidiness of dinnerware,
table. |
|
Accuracy |
20 |
Accuracy of items carried on tray;
accurate placement of items on table. |
Finishing Time |
20 |
Time taken to complete course. |
Scoring Criteria¡G
(¤@) Dress & Carriage 10%
Judges |
Scoring Criteria
|
Points
Deducted |
| Bar
Judges |
Girls¡¦ makeup too heavy.
|
1 |
| Rules regarding accessories not followed
(incorrect position of shoulder emblem, arms should be
free of rings & bracelets up to elbows, etc.) |
1 |
| Fingers dirty, nails too long (should
not grow past skin). |
1 |
| .Buttons on clothing either improperly
buttoned or unbuttoned. |
1 |
| .Hair not under control (short hair
should be tidy & not go past shoulder; long hair should
tied neatly in a bun). |
1 |
| Serviette dirty/untidy. |
1 |
| Clothing dirty/untidy. |
1 |
| Shoes dirty; not wearing all-black
shoes that cover entire foot (Student Division). |
1 |
| Uniform doesn¡¦t fit well. |
1 |
| 10.Unpleasant body odor or smell (including
strong perfume/cologne) |
1 |
| Subtotal |
10 |
Explanation of Scoring¡G
- As defined in the competition rules, Student Division
attire should consist of either team¡¦s school uniform or
basic service uniforms. Girls can wear either skirts or
pants. Points will be awarded based on the teams¡¦ uniformity
of dress, and for adherence to ¡§Dress and Carriage¡¨ scoring
criteria.
- Teams in the Professional Division should wear the same
company uniform or basic restaurant service uniform.
- Teams in the Professional Division can wear shoes or
sneakers, in accordance with their company¡¦s uniform specifications.
However, shoes must cover the entire foot & sandals
are not allowed.
- Contestants must provide their own serviettes, to be
draped over the arm carrying the tray. There are no restrictions
on the serviette¡¦s color or size, though it should be clean
and neatly presented. The contestant¡¦s overall dress must
be pleasing to the eye.
- Accessories (gloves, etc.) are permitted as long as they
don¡¦t violate competition rules (see ¡§Dress and Carriage¡¨
scoring criteria # 2).
(¤G) Safety & Hygiene10¢H
Judges |
Scoring
Criteria
|
Points
Deducted |
| Bar
Judges |
Contestant touches rim of glass while
picking up glass
|
2 |
| Contestant touches rim of water pitcher |
2 |
| Water drips on table during pouring, |
1 |
| Tabletop not kept clean, tidy |
1 |
| Not quiet during preparation of tray
items |
1 |
| Dinnerware dropped on floor while
walking |
2 |
| Violation of hygienic standards (touching
head, face, etc.) |
1 |
| Subtotal |
10 |
Explanation of Scoring¡G
During preparation, there is some flexibility in the sequence
of actions (lifting tray, pouring water, picking up glasses,
etc.). For example, both of the following are acceptable:
1. Lift tray into position„»place glasses„»pour water„»begin walking;
or 2. Pick up glasses„»pour water„»lift tray into position„»begin
walking. Contestants can use the method they are most comfortable
with as long they adhere to the required standard of safety
and cleanliness.
(¤T) Tray Carrying Posture & Steadiness40%
Judges |
Scoring
Criteria
|
Points
Deducted |
| Dining
Area Judges |
Tray carrying method not
according to standard (e.g. cannot touch chest/hip). |
1-3 |
| Steps unsteady; running with tray. |
1-3 |
| Body swaying or uneven; unsteady center
of gravity. |
1-3 |
| Body appears stiff; arms not moving
naturally. |
1-3 |
| Contestant drops tray or items fall
from tray onto floor (4 points will be deducted each time
items fall from tray onto ground); 2 points will be deducted
each time items fall over on tray; and 4 points will be
deducted each time contestant fails to return items to
correct position on tray) |
2-8 |
| Contestant not smiling, wearing a
serious/stiff facial expression |
1-3 |
| Contestant uses other hand to support
tray/dinnerware (3 points will be deducted each time;
a maximum of 8 points will be deducted for contestants
who continuously use other hand for support) |
3-8 |
| Back hunched, carriage improper. |
1-3 |
| Too much noise created while carrying
dinnerware. |
1-3 |
| Contestant bumps into other contestants,
table, etc. or crosses line. |
1-3 |
| Subtotal |
40 |
Explanation of Scoring¡G
- In scoring the ¡§Tray Carrying Posture and Steadiness¡¨
category, judges will look at both the process and result;
1 point will be deducted for each mistake, with a maximum
deduction of 3-8points per category.
- Tray carrying technique should be according to standard
described in competition rules.
(¥|) Accuracy20%
Judges |
Scoring
Criteria
|
Points
Deducted |
| Put-down
Area
Assistant Judges
|
Incorrect amount / wrong
kind of glasses (beverages) put on tray (1 point will
be deducted for each mistake, maximum deduction of 4 points).
|
1-4 |
| Water stains left on tray; tray not
kept clean. |
2 |
| Dinnerware not placed correctly/ in
a mess(1 point deducted for each mistake, maximum deduction
of 4 points) |
1-4 |
| Tall glass not filled to 80% (approx.
280ml). |
1-8 |
Water stains left on tabletop in put-down
area.
|
2 |
| Subtotal |
20 |
Explanation of Scoring¡G
- Contestant must put dinnerware, beverages, etc. on tray
exactly as specified in order,
and place items neatly on table.
- 2 points will be deducted for any water stains on trays,
regardless of size of spill.
- Tall glasses should be 80% full: if each glass is filled
to 280ml, the total water
volume for each contestant on Student Division teams should
be 1,680ml in the first round and 2,520ml in the finals.
In the Professional Division, each contestant must carry
a total of 560ml in the first round and 840ml in the finals.
If the team total (four members) is within the range of
plus/minus 5 ml, no points will be deducted; one point will
be deducted for plus/minus 5-10 ml; and 2 points deducted
for plus/minus10-15 ml.
(¤) Finishing Time20%
Judges |
Scoring
Criteria
|
Points
Deducted |
| Timekeeping
Teams |
Points awarded according
to finishing time. |
See Table 1 |
| Subtotal |
20 |
Explanation of Scoring¡G
- All times in the competition will be recorded by a ¡§Photo
Finish System¡¨ that conforms to AAF regulations, and is
certified by the ROC track and field authority.
- The Photo Finish System will be the main determinant for
competition times. In the
case of temporary malfunction, times will be recorded on
stopwatches operated by
assistant judges at each of the competition courses.
- For scoring method, please refer to Table 1.
Table 1: Scoring Chart for Finishing Times
|
Time |
Score |
¡Ø5 min
|
20 |
5 min 1 sec~ 5 min 15 sec |
18 |
5 min 16 sec~ 5 min 30 sec |
16 |
5 min31 sec~ 5 min 45 sec |
14 |
5 min 46 sec~ 6 min |
12 |
6min 1 sec~ 6 min 15 sec |
10 |
6 min 16 sec~ 6 min 30 sec |
8 |
6 min 31 sec~ 6 min 45 sec |
6 |
6 min 46 sec~ 7 min |
4 |
7 min 1 sec~ 7 min 15 sec |
2 |
Over 7 min 30 sec |
0 |
¡E |
Scoring¡G
Point deductions: Judges will deduct points
for mistakes made during both process and result; points
deducted in any individual category will be limited to
that category. For the same action, process or result,
points will only be deducted once.
|
| ¡E |
A perfect team score is 100 points. Team score = (Avg.
score of Dress & Carriage, Tray-Carrying Posture &
Steadiness, Safety & Cleanliness, and Accuracy categories
x 4 team members) + (Finishing Time category score)
|
| ¡E |
Rankings will be determined by team scores.
1. First Round: 12 top teams from Professional/Student
divisions will advance to finals.
2. Teams who forfeit will be replaced in finals by teams
with next-highest score.
3. The winners of the previous year¡¦s
Wowprime Cup (Professional Division: Lalu Hotel; Student
Division: Shih Chien University) will automatically advance
to the 2008 Wowprime Cup finals.
|
| ¡E |
In the case of a tie, the team with the lowest avg.
point deduction in different categories will be declared
the winner.
1. 1st category: Accuracy
2. 2nd category: Safety & Cleanliness
3. 3rd category: Tray-Carrying Posture & Steadiness
4. 4th category: Dress & Carriage
5. 5th category: Finishing Time |
|